Thin Ice is the Fargoesque story of a sleazy Wisconsin insurance agent whose small scam spins into a major crime. By the time that he gets into real trouble, he has already lied to everyone in his life so often, that no help is available.
Greg Kinnear plays the ethically challenged agent who is always “on”; if he asks you the time, you know that he is trying to turn your money into his money. Literally.
Kinnear is excellent, as is Alan Arkin as the old farmer that he is trying to fleece. Billy Crudup plays the psycho ex-con who becomes Kinnear’s unwelcome partner in crime. David Harbour shines as go-getter young salesman. So does Lea Thompson as Kinnear’s soon-to-be-ex-wife and Bob Balaban as a fastidious luthier (look it up if you have to). And keep your eye on Michelle Arthur, who plays Kinnear’s long suffering secretary.
Thin Ice is entertaining while Kinnear gets more and more entangled in his own web of lies and the pressure builds. The final reveal at the end (a loooong eight minutes or so of exposition) is kinda lame, and doesn’t stand up to the top films in the genre. Still, it’s a harmless and fun diversion.